"Why Tango in Paris, when you can Foxtrot in Kowloon?"
  • Walter's Blog.
  • Home
  • Introduction
  • About Walter
    • 1980 Joining Up - Grafton Street >
      • Arrival and First Impressions
      • First Week
      • Training
      • Passing Out
    • Yaumati Cowboy >
      • Getting on the Streets
      • Tempo of the City
      • Jumpers, pill poppers and the indoor BBQ
      • Into a Minefield.
    • Why Tango in Paris, when you can Foxtrot in Kowloon? >
      • Baptism By Fire
      • Kai Tak with Mrs Thatcher.
      • Home; The Boy Returns
  • 1984 - 1986
    • PTU Instructor & Getting Hitched
    • Having a go: SDU
    • Starting a Chernobyl family
    • EOD - Don't touch anything
    • Semen Stains and the rules
  • 1987 to 1992 - Should I Stay or Go?
    • Blue Lights, Sirens & Grenades
    • Drugs, Broken Kids & A Plane Crash
    • 600 Happy Meals Please!
    • Hong Kong's Best Insurance
    • Riding the Iron Horse
  • Crime in Hong Kong
    • Falling Crime Rates - Why?
    • Triads
  • History of Hong Kong Policing
    • History 1841 to 1941
    • History 1945 to 1967
    • Anatomy of the 50 cent Riot - 1966
    • The Fall of a Commissioner.
    • History 1967 to 1980
    • Three Wise Men from the West
    • The Blue Berets.
    • The African Korps and other tribes.
    • Getting About - Transport.
    • A Pub in every station
    • Bullshit Bingo & Meetings
    • Godber - The one who nearly got away.
    • Uncle Ho
  • Top 20 Films
    • 2001 - A Space Odyssey.
    • The Godfather.
    • Blade Runner
    • Kes
    • Star Wars
    • Aliens
    • Ferris Bueller's Day Off
    • The Life of Brian
    • Dr Strangelove.
    • Infernal Affairs
    • Bridge on the River Kwai.
    • This Is Spinal Tap.
    • Chung King Express
    • An Officer and a Gentleman
    • PTU
    • Contact
    • Saving Private Ryan
    • Family Guy Star Wars
    • Zulu
    • Hard Day's Night
  • The Long Read
    • How The Walls Come Down
    • War in Ukraine - the narrative and other stuff.
    • The Hidden Leader
    • The Big Game
  • Walter's Blog.
  • Home
  • Introduction
  • About Walter
    • 1980 Joining Up - Grafton Street >
      • Arrival and First Impressions
      • First Week
      • Training
      • Passing Out
    • Yaumati Cowboy >
      • Getting on the Streets
      • Tempo of the City
      • Jumpers, pill poppers and the indoor BBQ
      • Into a Minefield.
    • Why Tango in Paris, when you can Foxtrot in Kowloon? >
      • Baptism By Fire
      • Kai Tak with Mrs Thatcher.
      • Home; The Boy Returns
  • 1984 - 1986
    • PTU Instructor & Getting Hitched
    • Having a go: SDU
    • Starting a Chernobyl family
    • EOD - Don't touch anything
    • Semen Stains and the rules
  • 1987 to 1992 - Should I Stay or Go?
    • Blue Lights, Sirens & Grenades
    • Drugs, Broken Kids & A Plane Crash
    • 600 Happy Meals Please!
    • Hong Kong's Best Insurance
    • Riding the Iron Horse
  • Crime in Hong Kong
    • Falling Crime Rates - Why?
    • Triads
  • History of Hong Kong Policing
    • History 1841 to 1941
    • History 1945 to 1967
    • Anatomy of the 50 cent Riot - 1966
    • The Fall of a Commissioner.
    • History 1967 to 1980
    • Three Wise Men from the West
    • The Blue Berets.
    • The African Korps and other tribes.
    • Getting About - Transport.
    • A Pub in every station
    • Bullshit Bingo & Meetings
    • Godber - The one who nearly got away.
    • Uncle Ho
  • Top 20 Films
    • 2001 - A Space Odyssey.
    • The Godfather.
    • Blade Runner
    • Kes
    • Star Wars
    • Aliens
    • Ferris Bueller's Day Off
    • The Life of Brian
    • Dr Strangelove.
    • Infernal Affairs
    • Bridge on the River Kwai.
    • This Is Spinal Tap.
    • Chung King Express
    • An Officer and a Gentleman
    • PTU
    • Contact
    • Saving Private Ryan
    • Family Guy Star Wars
    • Zulu
    • Hard Day's Night
  • The Long Read
    • How The Walls Come Down
    • War in Ukraine - the narrative and other stuff.
    • The Hidden Leader
    • The Big Game
Search by typing & pressing enter

YOUR CART

Walter's Blog

"But how can you live and have no story to tell?" Fyodor Dostoevsky
Picture
Reflections on recent events, plus the occasional fact free rant unfiltered by rational argument. 

"If you want to read a blog to get a sense of what is going on in Hong Kong these days or a blog that would tell you wh at life was like living in colonial Hong Kong, this blog, WALTER'S BLOG, fits the bill."  Hong Kong Blog Review

31/3/2020 2 Comments

Something Doesn't Add Up!

Picture
"Everything appears inevitable once you get there, but we forget the journey."
There is much that is confusing about the Covid-19 virus pandemic. One so-called expert says 'wear a mask', even at home; and others say it's not necessary. To the layman, this is unsettling.

To make matters worse, the media and pundits misuse data. The death rate transfixes everyone. And yet, at best, the data is misleading; while at worst, it may drive responses that produce unwelcome outcomes.


It's worth restating that experts are only justified in their title and position when supported by evidence. Here is the immediate problem. The experts are deploying data that is dodgy.

In this blog, I'll examine the collection of data, its manifest flaws, misinterpretation and misuse. At times I'll argue against positions I took in earlier blogs to address the issues from all angles. 


As well as death rates, we have a morbid fascination with Covid-19 cases across nations to tally the numbers in a perverse competition. Again, the data is not up to the job. Let's examine why.

From the outset, we must be clear that the number of reported Covid-19 cases depends on the ability to detect the virus. Thus, if you live in a well-resourced place, with decent health services, detection is more likely.

​People in poorer countries, without testing, may conclude the virus hasn't reached them. This assumption is wrong. 


Next to consider is how the medical authorities elect to classify Covid-19, and, significantly, its role in any deaths. For starters, there is no agreed international standard nor classification tool-kit.

Thus, comparisons between places are problematic. Following that, you must decide what caused death. 


Was it Covid-19 or a pre-existing condition accelerated by the virus overwhelming the immune system? If a cancer patient tests positive for Covid-19, then dies, how can you decide the cause? In reality, this is tough.

​Get the figure wrong, and you may end up implementing precautions that cause more harm than the virus. 


To work out a death rate, we need three sets of numbers:-
  • The number of people infected with Covid-19
  • The number dying from or with the virus
  • A relevant period of time.

​Moreover, we need data over a large population to generate statistically significant results. Data must be adequate in quantity to removes the possibility of randomness — I won't get into that.


Consider the first set of data: the number of people infected with Covid-19. With a range of symptoms appearing over an incubation period of up to 14 days, deciding who to test is hard.

A clinical examination alone may not be adequate when Covid-19 symptoms overlap with the common cold and other ailments. Yet, testing everyone is prohibitively expensive.

​It ties up medical staff and resources when needed elsewhere. Also, we know a fair number of people exhibit mild symptoms or are asymptomatic.


From this, we can infer there are many more infected people than our regime of testing detects. In turn, this leads to the conclusion that the death rate is much lower than the available raw data suggests.

For example, as of 30 March 2020, we have 724,201 confirmed Covid-19 cases worldwide and 34,026 deaths. A death rate of 4.69%. 

Yet, if infection rates are ten to twenty times higher, as some research suggests, then the death rate drops.

Next, we need to consider the reported deaths and ask did the virus kill the patient? As mentioned above, underlying conditions are playing a role that we need to recognise. Without that distinction, we are at risk of overreacting by implementing measures that backfire. 

As an illustration, to what extent is the death rate increased by isolating vulnerable older people? Living under stressful conditions, with a lack of exercise, these people are at risk.

Stuck at home, tuned into a 24-hour news cycle, that portrays all deaths as Covid-19 related, is not conducive to good health. If these folks have a pre-existing condition, as many do, are we accelerating their demise? 


The third aspect is time. Again, without uniform standards of measurement and the lag in gathering data, interpretation is hampered.

There is some agreement that Germany is accurately recording Covid-19 within its population by a high testing rate. Plus, they have a relatively high level of critical care — 29 beds per 100,000. Their death rate is currently 0.8%, which is similar to seasonal flu.

Meanwhile, virologists are coming to a consensus that Covid-19 will eventually infect 90% of the world's population.

Further, there is compelling evidence that the virus has been circulating for years undetected. The Lombardy region of Italy reported unusual cases of flu in November 2019, just before the Wuhan outbreak. 


So, what can we conclude from all this? 

  • Covid-19 is much more wide-spread than the data suggests, and people are carrying the virus unaware.
  • Covid-19 is more likely to kill you if you have an underlying condition; thus, by default, the elderly are at risk - 73% of the UK dead are over 75 years old.
  • Death rates are difficult to determine, although at this time Covid-19 compares to seasonal flu.

Tuned into a 24-hour news cycle with its relentless focus on exponential graphs of Covid-19 cases and deaths, is bound to panic people.

​Layered atop that is 'Carol on Facebook' who is suddenly the go-to expert on Covid-19. Her often unhelpful rumours add to the psychological impact that drives panic buying of toilet paper. 


At times analysing the data feels callous, because behind it all are individual stories of people and impacted communities. That doesn't devalue its importance nor the importance of recognising its limitations.

As I say, without international standards for the classification of Covid-19 and recording deaths, comparisons between places are somewhat incoherent.


Add to that the reduced air pollution and road traffic, resulting in fewer deaths across populations, and you can see the picture is complicated.

How many other diseases are held in check by the precautions we've taken? Could it be that overall death rates reduce? 
​

Everything appears inevitable once you get there, but we forget the journey. We must ask, are we creating a predetermined higher death rate by confining the elderly and others to home? I don't know the answer. 

​We humans have a great hunger for explanation. In this instance, that explanation may have to wait until we get a fuller picture and verified evidence. 
2 Comments
Julian Williams
11/4/2020 02:23:39 am

Another compelling article, Walter.

Re. "The Lombardy region of Italy reported unusual cases of flu in November 2019, just before the Wuhan outbreak", isn't there a particularly high number of Chinese workers (including from Wuhan?) in Lombardy, given the business links between Italy and China? In which case, it would have been entirely feasible for an infected Chinese worker to have introduced SARS-CoV-2 to Lombardy, I suppose.

Regards,

Julian Williams

Reply
Juan
13/4/2020 06:43:08 am

Look at death charts from all causes.. In the hard hit places there's a definite spike upwards.

From The New York Times: Deaths in New York City Are More Than Double the Usual Total Deaths from all causes have surged, undermining arguments that coronavirus numbers have been overblown. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/04/10/upshot/coronavirus-deaths-new-york-city.html?smid

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Walter De Havilland was one of the last of the colonial coppers. He served 35 years in the Royal Hong Kong Police and Hong Kong Police Force. He's long retired. 

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017

Home

Introduction

Contact Walter

Copyright © 2015