"Why Tango in Paris, when you can Foxtrot in Kowloon?"
  • Walter's Blog.
  • Home
  • Introduction
  • About Walter
    • 1980 Joining Up - Grafton Street >
      • Arrival and First Impressions
      • First Week
      • Training
      • Passing Out
    • Yaumati Cowboy >
      • Getting on the Streets
      • Tempo of the City
      • Jumpers, pill poppers and the indoor BBQ
      • Into a Minefield.
    • Why Tango in Paris, when you can Foxtrot in Kowloon? >
      • Baptism By Fire
      • Kai Tak with Mrs Thatcher.
      • Home; The Boy Returns
  • 1984 - 1986
    • PTU Instructor & Getting Hitched
    • Having a go: SDU
    • Starting a Chernobyl family
    • EOD - Don't touch anything
    • Semen Stains and the rules
  • 1987 to 1992 - Should I Stay or Go?
    • Blue Lights, Sirens & Grenades
    • Drugs, Broken Kids & A Plane Crash
    • 600 Happy Meals Please!
    • Hong Kong's Best Insurance
    • Riding the Iron Horse
  • Crime in Hong Kong
    • Falling Crime Rates - Why?
    • Triads
  • History of Hong Kong Policing
    • History 1841 to 1941
    • History 1945 to 1967
    • Anatomy of the 50 cent Riot - 1966
    • The Fall of a Commissioner.
    • History 1967 to 1980
    • Three Wise Men from the West
    • The Blue Berets.
    • The African Korps and other tribes.
    • Getting About - Transport.
    • A Pub in every station
    • Bullshit Bingo & Meetings
    • Godber - The one who nearly got away.
    • Uncle Ho
  • Top 20 Films
    • 2001 - A Space Odyssey.
    • The Godfather.
    • Blade Runner
    • Kes
    • Star Wars
    • Aliens
    • Ferris Bueller's Day Off
    • The Life of Brian
    • Dr Strangelove.
    • Infernal Affairs
    • Bridge on the River Kwai.
    • This Is Spinal Tap.
    • Chung King Express
    • An Officer and a Gentleman
    • PTU
    • Contact
    • Saving Private Ryan
    • Family Guy Star Wars
    • Zulu
    • Hard Day's Night
  • The Long Read
    • How The Walls Come Down
    • War in Ukraine - the narrative and other stuff.
    • The Hidden Leader
    • The Big Game
  • Walter's Blog.
  • Home
  • Introduction
  • About Walter
    • 1980 Joining Up - Grafton Street >
      • Arrival and First Impressions
      • First Week
      • Training
      • Passing Out
    • Yaumati Cowboy >
      • Getting on the Streets
      • Tempo of the City
      • Jumpers, pill poppers and the indoor BBQ
      • Into a Minefield.
    • Why Tango in Paris, when you can Foxtrot in Kowloon? >
      • Baptism By Fire
      • Kai Tak with Mrs Thatcher.
      • Home; The Boy Returns
  • 1984 - 1986
    • PTU Instructor & Getting Hitched
    • Having a go: SDU
    • Starting a Chernobyl family
    • EOD - Don't touch anything
    • Semen Stains and the rules
  • 1987 to 1992 - Should I Stay or Go?
    • Blue Lights, Sirens & Grenades
    • Drugs, Broken Kids & A Plane Crash
    • 600 Happy Meals Please!
    • Hong Kong's Best Insurance
    • Riding the Iron Horse
  • Crime in Hong Kong
    • Falling Crime Rates - Why?
    • Triads
  • History of Hong Kong Policing
    • History 1841 to 1941
    • History 1945 to 1967
    • Anatomy of the 50 cent Riot - 1966
    • The Fall of a Commissioner.
    • History 1967 to 1980
    • Three Wise Men from the West
    • The Blue Berets.
    • The African Korps and other tribes.
    • Getting About - Transport.
    • A Pub in every station
    • Bullshit Bingo & Meetings
    • Godber - The one who nearly got away.
    • Uncle Ho
  • Top 20 Films
    • 2001 - A Space Odyssey.
    • The Godfather.
    • Blade Runner
    • Kes
    • Star Wars
    • Aliens
    • Ferris Bueller's Day Off
    • The Life of Brian
    • Dr Strangelove.
    • Infernal Affairs
    • Bridge on the River Kwai.
    • This Is Spinal Tap.
    • Chung King Express
    • An Officer and a Gentleman
    • PTU
    • Contact
    • Saving Private Ryan
    • Family Guy Star Wars
    • Zulu
    • Hard Day's Night
  • The Long Read
    • How The Walls Come Down
    • War in Ukraine - the narrative and other stuff.
    • The Hidden Leader
    • The Big Game
Search by typing & pressing enter

YOUR CART

Walter's Blog

"But how can you live and have no story to tell?" Fyodor Dostoevsky
Picture
Reflections on recent events, plus the occasional fact free rant unfiltered by rational argument. 

"If you want to read a blog to get a sense of what is going on in Hong Kong these days or a blog that would tell you wh at life was like living in colonial Hong Kong, this blog, WALTER'S BLOG, fits the bill."  Hong Kong Blog Review

27/2/2023 0 Comments

On the Fringe

Picture
"Arguably, Hong Kong was built on parallel trading because we've always leveraged differences between the Mainland and us to generate business."
They're back! Once the Mainland crossing points re-opened, it didn't take long for Hong Kong's savvy parallel traders to swing into action. Likewise, Mainlanders are lining up outside luxury goods shops in Central to buy the latest LV bag or Gucci item.

But, of course, nobody is raising a hue and crying about Pedder Street's queues as the visitors swipe their credit cards. That's the acceptable face of parallel trading.


Yet further north, the grumbling is already gathering pace as the more grass-roots parallel traders reappear in Sheung Shui. The phenomenon is not new. Don't forget it played a role in the now defunct localist movement that sought to stir up anti-Mainlander sentiment.

A series of protests starting in 2011, led to near riots in 2015, with those opposing the trade scuffled with traders and their supporters. Driving the militant end of the discontent were elements intent on inciting hatred. Some of that was a foretaste of what came along in 2019. Still, genuine public disquiet at the social disturbance caused by the parallel trade existed.

In this blog post, I will sweep through the history of parallel trading in Hong Kong, mentioning the current regulations and the potential benefits and drawbacks. Finally, I'll consider possible solutions.

So what is parallel trading, and why is it a cause of concern? Parallel traders buy products in Hong Kong at lower prices and sell them in Shenzhen at higher prices. The business model is that simple. 

However, the term' parallel trading' is probably confusing the issue. What is happening is more akin to smuggling and grey trading. Thus, it's essential to distinguish between legal and illegal; parallel trading becomes unlawful if the trademark owner's consent is not given according to Section 20 of the Trade Marks Ordinance, Chapter 559, Laws of Hong Kong.

According to a Hong Kong Trade Development Council study, legal parallel trading in Hong Kong was estimated at around US$24 billion in 2020. This figure includes exports and imports of goods shipped through Hong Kong. Most of these goods are sourced from mainland China and then resold in other countries, primarily in the Asia-Pacific region.

Unfortunately, I've got no data on the value of grey trading, except to say it must be lucrative given the scale of the operations visible in Sheung Shui and elsewhere. 

While this trade existed for decades, these days, syndicates bulk buy everyday items from shops in Sheung Shui, Fanling and further afield. The articles are then broken down into individual loads and distributed to couriers, who travel across the boundary to hand over the items.

The explosion in this grey trading can be traced back to 2003 when the 'Individual Visit Scheme' was implemented, allowing multiple boundary crossings and creating the means for the trade to flourish. 

To some extent, the trade caters to a market created by the sudden appearance of Shenzhen's middle-class population by offering them cheaper genuine goods. Moreover, past shortages in the Mainland and concerns around the quality of such items as child milk powder drove demand to new heights. Hong Kong suffered as mothers here couldn't source milk powder. 

And yet, this type of trading is universal as it allows merchants to take advantage of price differences between the two markets. And, arguably, Hong Kong was built on parallel trading because we've always leveraged differences between the Mainland and us to generate business.

Hence these traders, seen by some as a blight, are the manifestations of an activity that helped make Hong Kong a success. Further, all involved are gainfully employed, making a living and not reliant on the state for benefits. If you look at the couriers, the majority are middle or old-aged, who struggle to find gainful employment elsewhere. They earn as much as HK$1000 a trip, making the work lucrative.

Parallel trading can also help manufacturers by boosting demand and increasing sales, brand recognition and profits. Yet, the impact of the trade on its host community, mainly Sheung Shui, is visible and significant. I'll get to that. 

At a more macro level, economists tell us that such grey trading can decrease the demand for goods in the domestic market, as traders can buy the goods in other jurisdictions and sell them at a lower price. As a result, this trade can lead to decreased sales for domestic companies and a drop in overall economic activity. 

Furthermore, this business can distort price signals, as the prices for goods in the domestic market may no longer reflect the actual underlying demand for the items. 

Finally, parallel trading can impact the government's ability to collect taxes on the goods purchased and sold. Yet, none of these macro factors is driving the discontent at the trade here in Hong Kong. 

For many years now, with an interlude for Covid, it is the more mundane issues of obstruction, noise, litter, and the general nuisance traders create that raised concerns. For example, at Sheung Shui Station, traders mainly gather near Exit C to exchange goods, causing a severe blockage. In response, the MTR erected barriers and gates to control the situation, with staff enforcing the rules. Alas, this led to disputes and conflict with Police reinforcements needed to restore order.

Faced with public discontent, the government sought to regulate the trade by imposing strict limits on the number of goods carried at any time. For example, limits on how much milk powder an individual may have; the law states that any person carrying more than 1.8kg of powdered formula when leaving Hong Kong may face a maximum fine of HK$500,000 and two years imprisonment. 

Nonetheless, the scale of the challenge is enormous. According to statistics from the Hong Kong Immigration Department, about 2.43 million people entered and exited through the control points from February 6th to 12th. Stopping, checking and searching even a tiny proportion of these people requires considerable time and resources.

Still, the current government's response is piecemeal, involving tweaking regulations and ad-hoc enforcement action by various agencies, including the Customs and Excise Department. 

The authorities must recognise that uncoordinated actions such as sweeps that pick up couriers and ticketing obstruction will only have a marginal impact.

Ultimately, it is perfectly possible to disrupt the trade with an intelligence-led operation coordinated across multiple agencies to tackle the money moved around. That will hurt the syndicates. 

I've heard pundits suggest that parallel trading is a tangible demonstration that 'one-country, two-systems’ remains intact. There is an element of truth in that. However, such a stance does not assuage the poor residents of Sheung Shui overwhelmed by the disruption to their community. 

0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Walter De Havilland was one of the last of the colonial coppers. He served 35 years in the Royal Hong Kong Police and Hong Kong Police Force. He's long retired. 

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017

Home

Introduction

Contact Walter

Copyright © 2015